What to do when you owe more on your car than it's worth
Being "upside down" on a car loan means you owe more on it than the car would sell for. It's a common spot to be in, and an uncomfortable one, because the usual ways out — selling or trading the car — don't cover what you still owe.
There's rarely a program that simply pays off the gap for you. What does exist is a set of moves that either close the gap over time or keep it from getting worse, plus some limited help if losing the car would cost you your job. This page walks through them, roughly in the order most people should consider them.
How you ended up here matters less than what you do next. Some people bought more car than the budget could handle or took a very long loan; others were hit by a job loss, a medical crisis, or a car that lost value faster than expected. Either way, the options below are the same.
First, know how deep you are
Before you decide anything, pin down two numbers: what your car is worth right now, and what you actually owe. Look up your car's current trade-in value for its year, mileage, and condition, and ask your lender for the exact payoff amount, fees included. The difference between the two is your gap — and whether it's a few hundred dollars or several thousand changes which options make sense.
Suppose your car would trade in for $12,000, but your lender says the payoff amount is $16,500. You’re upside down by $4,500. That gap is what you need to solve — either by paying it down, covering it with cash, or finding a way to reduce the overall cost of the loan.
Start with free advice
Before you borrow anything or make a big move, it's worth a conversation with a nonprofit credit counselor. A first session is usually free, and they'll look at the car loan alongside the rest of your budget and debts, then lay out what's realistic for you. They can't make the gap vanish, but they can help you avoid a costly mistake and point you to the right next step. You can find one through our guide to nonprofit credit counseling agencies.
The realistic ways out
There are a handful of legitimate options to look ointo, and the right one depends on the size of your gap and whether you can keep making the payments.
Selling and downsizing is the best option when you can manage it. If you can cover the gap with savings, or it's small enough to pay off, selling the car and buying something cheaper — ideally paid for in cash — stops the monthly expense. It's a hard reset, but it ends the problem rather than extending it.
Keeping the car and paying it down faster works if the payments are manageable and you're close to even. Putting anything extra toward the principal each month closes the gap sooner, and once the car is worth more than you owe, you have additional options to explore at that point.
Refinancing can lower your interest rate or monthly payment if your credit has improved or rates have dropped since you bought. It won't erase the gap, and a longer term means more interest overall, so treat it as short term relief than a long term fix. Our guide to refinancing an auto loan covers how it works.
Rolling the balance into a new car loan is something dealers will offer if you're shopping for another vehicle, but it usually makes things worse — it takes your gap and adds it to a bigger new loan, so you start the next car underwater too. It's worth understanding before anyone talks you into it; here's an honest look at a car loan rollover and when it does and doesn't make sense.
If you're leasing rather than buying, ask about a lease buyout — purchasing the car at its set price and then reselling it can sometimes recover part of the cost. That one only applies to leases, not loans.
If the car is tied to your job
The one place limited outside help shows up is when losing the car would also cost you your income. Some local nonprofits and community programs offer low-cost car loans, help with a repair, or access to a reliable used vehicle for people who need transportation to keep working. This help is scarce and usually reserved for exactly that situation — a hardship that threatens your livelihood.
Your local community action agency is a good place to ask, since they know what's available in your area and can point you toward employment and transportation support. There are also charities and programs that provide a donated or low-cost vehicle in cases of real need; our guide to free and low-cost car programs lists them.
If you need to borrow, borrow smart
Sometimes people bridge a gap by borrowing, and if you go that route, the source matters enormously. A small-dollar loan from a credit union — including their payday alternative loans — costs a fraction of what a payday or car-title lender charges, and those can put you into further debt than the car loan did. Start with our guide to loans from credit unions, and steer clear of payday and title lenders when you're already struggling.
This page is general information, not legal or financial advice. Options, loan terms, and which programs are available depend on your lender, your credit, and where you live. A nonprofit credit counselor or your own lender can help you weigh what's right for your situation.
Related Content From Needhelppayingbills.com
|
Need help navigating programs?