Finding the best debt consolidation loan for your situation
If you are shopping for a loan to combine your debts, the advertisements in front of you will disagree with each other. One lender claims the lowest rate, another the fastest funding, another no fees at all. None of those claims tells you which loan will cost you the least.
There is no best consolidation loan for everyone. Lenders price each loan on the applicant's credit history, income, and existing debt, so the same lender quotes very different rates to different people. The best loan for you is the one with the lowest total cost among the offers you actually qualify for, and the only way to find it is to collect several real offers and compare them all the same way.
This page covers how to do that: which kinds of lenders to include, how to gather offers without damaging your credit, the numbers that decide which offer wins, and the loan offers to refuse no matter how good they sound. What a consolidation loan is and how using one works is covered separately in the NHPB guide to using a loan to consolidate debt.
- PRO TIP & SCAM WARNING: No advertisement can name the best consolidation loan for you, because no advertiser has seen your credit file. Collect real prequalified offers, put the total cost of each side by side, and take the cheapest one whose payment fits your budget - any company or offer that promises a way to eliminate your debt is a red flag.
The three kinds of lenders to include
Credit unions are member-owned and not run for profit, and for people with ordinary or imperfect credit they are often where the lowest rates turn up. Joining one usually takes little effort, since many accept members based on where you live or work. If you check only one type of lender beyond the ads you have already seen, make it a credit union.
Banks sometimes offer better pricing to people who already hold accounts with them, so the bank you use now is worth a quote, though their approval standards tend to run stricter than other lenders'.
Online lenders approve the widest range of credit profiles and move the fastest, and they also show the widest spread in pricing. The rate in an online lender's advertisement belongs to its strongest applicants, and the offer you personally receive can sit far above it, which is exactly why collecting real quotes matters more than reading ads.
Gather offers without hurting your credit
Nearly every lender will quote you an estimated rate through prequalification before a formal application. The estimate comes from a soft review of your credit, the kind that leaves no mark on your score, and it obligates you to nothing. Collect prequalified quotes from several lenders spread across the three types above.
One way to see several quotes from a single form is a loan marketplace, where multiple lenders respond to one request; the NHPB guide to how loan aggregator sites work explains what those platforms do and how to use them carefully.
A formal application is different. It involves a hard credit check that can lower your score a little, so save it for the single offer you choose. And treat every prequalified number as an estimate: the final rate is set after the lender verifies your income and runs the full check, and it can come back higher than the quote.
Two maintained comparison pages are also useful while you gather quotes. Bankrate keeps a page of current debt consolidation loan offers with prequalification at https://www.bankrate.com/loans/personal-loans/debt-consolidation-loans and Experian runs a free debt consolidation loan marketplace matched to your credit standing at https://www.experian.com/loans/debt-consolidation. Both mostly display offers from lenders they work with, so use them alongside a credit union quote rather than in place of one.
The numbers that decide which offer wins
The figure that makes offers comparable is the APR. Two loans can advertise the same interest rate and cost very different amounts once fees are counted, and the APR folds the origination fee into a single yearly cost. When two offers run the same length, the lower APR is the cheaper loan.
Understand how the origination fee is collected, because it changes how much to borrow. Most lenders that charge one deduct it from the loan money before you receive anything. If you need $7,500 to pay off your debts and the loan carries a 5 percent fee, $375 comes out first and only $7,125 reaches you, which leaves you short. Ask each lender whether its fee is deducted from the proceeds or added to the balance, and size your request so the amount you actually receive covers the full payoff. Some lenders charge no origination fee at all, which is worth asking about directly.
Watch the advertised rate's lifespan too. Some consolidation loan offers lead with a low rate that lasts only for an opening period before rising, a pattern the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau warns about in its comparison of consolidation, counseling, and settlement services at https://www.consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb/what-is-the-difference-between-credit-counseling-and-debt-settlement-debt-consolidation-or-credit-repair-en-1449/. Confirm in writing that the rate quoted is fixed for the life of the loan.
Then look past the rate entirely and compute the total: multiply the monthly payment by the number of months, add every fee, and set that figure beside the same figure from each other offer. This is the only fair way to compare loans of different lengths, because a longer repayment period buys a smaller payment at the price of more total interest. That tradeoff is worked through with examples on the NHPB page about weighing the benefits and risks of debt consolidation </a>; the short version is to take the shortest term whose payment your budget can support.
Two smaller terms round out the checklist. Confirm there is no penalty for paying the loan off early, and choose a different lender if there is one. And many lenders trim the rate slightly for automatic payments, which is worth taking as long as the underlying offer already wins the comparison.
If every offer you qualify for is poor
Sometimes the prequalified quotes come back sitting near what your debts already charge, and a consolidation that saves nothing is not worth its fees. That result is information, and it points to other options.
You can wait and improve your standing first, since even a modest rise in your credit score changes the offers you receive; the NHPB guide to how credit is repaired and rebuilt after debt problems covers what moves a score and how long it takes. Some community and marketplace lending platforms also approve applicants that banks decline, described in the NHPB guide to marketplace loan options and community lending alternatives.
And one consolidation method needs no loan approval at all. A debt management plan through a nonprofit agency arranges lower rates with your existing creditors regardless of your score, and agencies are listed in the NHPB directory of nonprofit agencies that provide free credit counseling. The rest of the alternatives are laid out in the NHPB overview of the main types of debt consolidation.
Loans to refuse no matter how good they sound
People searching for consolidation loans, especially with damaged credit, are the exact audience of the advance-fee loan scam. The pattern is consistent: a company guarantees you a loan regardless of your credit history, then requires a payment before the money arrives, called a processing fee, an insurance fee, or an application charge. After you pay, there is no loan, and the company disappears.
Two facts expose the scam every time. A legitimate lender never guarantees approval before reviewing your credit, and a legitimate lender's fees come out of the loan money at funding rather than being collected from you in advance. Any request to pay first, and especially to pay by wire transfer or gift card, ends the conversation. The Federal Trade Commission's page on what to know about advance-fee loans at https://consumer.ftc.gov/articles/what-know-about-advance-fee-loans lists the warning signs and where to report these companies. It also helps to confirm that any unfamiliar lender is licensed to lend in your state, which your state's banking or financial regulator can tell you.
This page describes how to shop for and compare debt consolidation loans in general terms. The rates, fees, and approval standards you encounter are set by each lender based on your credit and income, and they change without notice. Nothing here is financial or legal advice. If you are unsure whether a loan is the right step at all, a nonprofit credit counselor can go over your options at no cost.
Related Content From Needhelppayingbills.com
|
Need help navigating programs?